Ever since the Leahy-Smith America Invents Act was passed by the 112th Congress in 2011, inventors have been discouraged to innovate by failing to secure the exclusive rights to their inventions through a patent.
It was bad enough that the Act changed patent law from a “first to invent” to “a first to file” for patents. It also created new and easier ways to invalidate an existing patent. Prior to this, to invalidate a patent required going to a judicial court with a jury and its various protections offered to the holder of a property right. The Act created procedures for an administrative court, the PTAB (Patent Trial and Appeals Board), that does not have the same protections. PTAB has become a nightmare for inventors because it allows infringers to challenge the validity of patents in the PTAB. Some inventors have faced hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal expense and annihilation of their patent rights in unlimited third-party patent validity challenges. Serial petitions are common with valuable patents suffering a dozen or more attacks with costs typically being in excess of $350,000 for each PTAB defense.
Some inventors have endured up to a decade and spent tens of millions of dollars in legal expense to obtain a final judgment in court against infringers of their patent. Even then, inventors have not been not compensated fairly or sufficiently to prevent infringement of their patent rights.
For example, in the Amazon documentary, Invalidated: The Shredding of the U.S. Patent System, Josh Malone, the inventor of Bunch O Balloons, stated that his court case against Telebrands has cost over $20M. It also documented how Dan Phillips, inventor of the Bionic Wrench, has been fighting Sears in court since 2012. A judge recently tossed out the jury verdict that held Sears liable because of their bankruptcy. I understand his appeal process will take several more years. (Note: The full version is available now on Amazon and iTunes)
It’s not just China that is stealing our technology; it is U.S.-based corporations stealing technology from inventors right and left. Google, Apple, Amazon, Telebrands and other big corporations are getting away with profiting from pirated product. Why should large corporations be allowed to steal inventions and block access to the legal system for private inventors and small businesses? How can a small business survive if it takes a decade and millions of dollars in legal expense to protect intellectual property rights?
According to Randy Landreneau, President of US Inventor, Inc., “Current policies and case law focus instead on patents as monetary assets held by corporations, injecting extremely high cost and risk to enforcing any single patent and making patent enforcement a ‘game of kings.’ Big corporations play the game by hiring dozens of lawyers, hoarding hundreds of patents, and pouring millions of dollars into litigation. Inventors cannot play that game and need a viable path to enforce their patent rights because PTAB rulings have canceled claims in 85% of issued patents. This is disheartening and discouraging to inventors and startups in our community.”
He added, “In the rare instance that the PTAB permits an inventor to keep his patent, there is no monetary recovery. This means the inventor has nothing to offer a law firm to take the case on a contingency basis. Pro bono defense is not available either. Inventors with valuable inventions have virtually no chance of keeping their patents in the PTAB.”
Last year three
bills were introduced to Congress to protect inventors rights, but these bills
never got out of committee for a vote on the House floor:
H.R.6557,
Inventor Protection Act – “To amend title 35,
United States Code, to restore patent rights to inventors, and for other
purposes.” It was designed to restore patent protection for inventors by
reversing a generation of laws and regulations.
S.1390, Stronger Patents Act of 2017 – A bill to strengthen the position of the United States as the world’s leading innovator by amending title 35, United States Code, to protect the property rights of the inventors that grow the country’s economy.
H.R.6264 – Restoring America’s Leadership in Innovation Act of 2018 – A bill “to promote the leadership of the United States in global innovation by establishing a robust patent system that restores and protects the right of inventors to own and enforce private property rights in inventions and discoveries, and for other purposes.”
In order to foster the development of American manufacturing, Article I, Section 8, Clause 8
of the Constitution states that the Congress shall have the power “To
promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times
to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and
Discoveries.”
This enabled America to become the world leader in innovation, driven largely by this simple yet profound promise to inventors of the exclusive right to their discoveries. Without secure patent rights, inventors are starved of time and capital required to explore and develop new technologies. Today, the United States faces an escalating innovation crisis as we are forced to rely on outdated or imported technologies. Congress must act quickly to restore reliable patent rights for inventors.
As a mentor for San Diego’s CONNECT Springboard accelerator program for a few years and a director on the board of the San Diego Inventors Forum, I work with inventors designing new products or break-through technologies. Local inventors have the opportunity to compete in the San Diego Inventors Forum annual invention contest for best new consumer product or best new technology. All contestants must have applied for at least a provisional patent before they can participate. The future success of their product or technology is contingent upon their having a patent they can protect from infringement. Their ability to raise the financial investment they need to bring their product to the marketplace depends upon their being able to protect their patent.
Why is this important? Because most new technologies, especially break-through or disruptive technologies, come from individual inventors who either start a company or license their technology to companies that are more able to take them to the market. It is critical for inventors to be able to have some assurance that the rights to their patents will be reviewed in a consistent manner so that they will be able to secure investors and get their product into the marketplace.
Inventors must be equipped and motivated to apply their knowledge and creativity to solving problems. In order to encourage inventors to share their discovery in exchange for a time-limited exclusive right, patents owned by the original inventor must be protected from the policies that target assets held and traded by non-inventors.
The United States must retake the lead in the next wave of technological innovation in areas like quantum computing, artificial intelligence, and medical diagnostics. Protection for discoveries is these fields is the absolute best way to promote progress in science and useful arts in our modern day.
US Inventors started off The Inventor’s Project in February by co-hosting an open house on Capitol Hill with the Congressional Inventions Caucus. A bipartisan group of Congressional members and staff attended. As a result, the Inventions Caucus will continue to grow and support the mission of educating Congress on the importance of innovation and small inventors and promote the Inventor Rights Resolution.
SUMMARY OF THE RESOLUTION
Our patent system is in crisis. Recent changes to patent laws and Supreme Court decisions have adversely affected inventors such that the requirement in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution of “securing for limited times to inventors the exclusive right to their discoveries” is no longer achieved. It is nearly impossible to stop an infringer from using an invention without permission, or to make them to pay for the damage caused when they do. The undersigned inventors call on Congress to pass legislation to address these critical issues.
PTAB
The USPTO Must Stop Taking Back Patents from Inventors
INJUNCTIONS
Courts must prohibit the use of a patented invention without permission
PROFITS
Infringers must not profit by using an invention without permission
We must stop the America Invents Act from gradually destroying the American Patent System. We need to encourage our own Congressional Representative to co-sponsor or support an Inventor Rights Act to restore our rights as inventors in this Congress and reinvigorate the famous American innovation system. Join us by signing the Inventor Rights Resolution